
AS Roma are reportedly pursuing an unusual transfer target: according to consistent reports from Italy and Mexico, the Giallorossi are in concrete negotiations with Club América over the signing of centre-back Israel Reyes. The 23-year-old Mexican is regarded at his home club as a solid defender and has recently drawn attention in the Liga MX. Now the move to Serie A is said to follow.
Talks between the two clubs are ongoing, but a deal is not yet considered certain. Club América are said to be holding firm on a transfer fee, while Roma are still sounding out the terms. Whether the transfer ultimately happens should be decided in the coming days. Sporting director Florent Ghisolfi is examining the deal as part of broader squad planning for the defence.
From an analytical perspective, however, the verdict is clear: the PLAIER rating classes Reyes unmistakably as a transfer minus. According to this assessment, the defender sits below Roma's current squad level and would not make the team better. The underlying figures also give little cause for hope: Reyes has an xGoals value of 0.0 and, with an xPoints contribution of likewise 0.0, contributes barely measurably to a team's strength. These numbers suggest that he adds value neither offensively nor in terms of on-pitch value creation.
For Roma, who are under sporting pressure in Serie A and urgently need stability, this transfer would therefore be hard to understand. Should the deal nevertheless go through, those in charge would have to explain which qualities beyond the measurable data they see in Reyes. The numbers, at any rate, tell a different story.


