
Rangers have wrapped up their next summer signing: Olwethu Makhanya is moving from Philadelphia Union to the Scottish club in the Scottish Premiership. The transfer has been officially confirmed and marks the South African winger's step from Major League Soccer onto the European stage.
On paper the deal sounds interesting, but a sober analysis dampens the enthusiasm considerably. Our PLAIER rating is clearly negative: Makhanya does not make the team better and, as things stand, sits below the existing squad level at Rangers. For a club with title ambitions in the Premiership and European aspirations, that is a problematic signal.
Things get especially critical when looking at the performance data. Makhanya posts zero Expected Goals and zero Expected Points, meaning no measurable value contribution in the key metrics that matter for transfers. This suggests the player left hardly any statistical trace during his time at Philadelphia Union. For a market value of 11.7 million euros, one should be able to expect considerably more, both in attacking involvement and in influence on match results.
With this transfer, Rangers risk investing valuable squad resources in a player who, based on the current data picture, is unlikely to make a noticeable difference. Of course a player can develop further in a new environment, but for now the numbers speak a clear language. Fans and club management can look forward with curiosity to whether Makhanya proves the doubters wrong, as the burden of proof clearly lies with him.


