
Mexican striker Santiago Gimenez is reportedly on the verge of a surprise move within Europe. According to well-informed sources, FC Porto and AC Milan are currently in concrete negotiations over a transfer of the 23-year-old forward. Gimenez, who was most recently under contract with the Rossoneri, could soon join the Portuguese Primeira Liga, taking a step back to a league in which he once began his European career.
From a sporting perspective, however, this transfer raises considerable questions. The PLAIER analysis, a data-based rating system for transfer decisions, reaches a clear conclusion: Gimenez would not make FC Porto better. The assessment is clearly negative, as the striker currently sits below the existing squad level of the Portuguese side. His expected contribution is rated at 0.0 xGoals and 0.0 xPoints, which means that, statistically speaking, neither goals nor points are expected from him for the team.
The financial aspect also deserves attention. Santiago Gimenez's Fair Market Value is currently estimated at around 14.6 million euros. Whether Porto is willing to invest this sum, and whether Milan will accept this demand, remains to be seen. Given the meager data, such an investment appears at least debatable from Porto's perspective.
Overall, the final assessment suggests that this transfer can hardly be justified from a sporting point of view. It would be advisable for Porto to critically question the negotiations and focus on alternatives that could actually raise the squad level. The outcome of the talks nevertheless remains open.


