Home / Premier League / Manuel Ugarte
Rumour: Manuel Ugarte → Newcastle United

Ugarte to Newcastle: no gain, says PLAIER

No gainPremier League, RumourBench
14 April 2026 at 10:00 · 1 min read
Manuel Ugarte
No gainWould not make the best starting line-up
Goals per season0
Fair market value€26.2m
FromManchester United
ToNewcastle United

Manchester United could part ways with Manuel Ugarte as early as this winter. After just a few months at Old Trafford, the Uruguayan midfielder is reportedly on the verge of a move to Newcastle United. The 23-year-old, who was signed from Paris Saint-Germain for around 50 million euros only last summer, has failed to establish himself and is considered a potential sale.

Ugarte never really got going at the Red Devils and has fallen short of expectations. Manager Ruben Amorim is increasingly relying on other options in central midfield, leaving the South American mostly playing a bit-part role. Manchester United apparently want to free up squad space while generating funds for other transfers.

Newcastle United are showing concrete interest in the defensive midfielder, though experts are critical of this potential transfer. The PLAIER analysis concludes that Ugarte would not improve the team and falls below the current squad level of the Magpies. With an estimated market value of 26.2 million euros, he would be available for significantly less than originally invested.

Negotiations between both clubs are said to be underway, with Newcastle preferring a loan deal with purchase option. Manchester United, however, are pushing for a direct sale to quickly resolve the failed signing. Ugarte himself is reportedly not opposed to the move as he hopes for more playing time. A decision could be made before the transfer window closes.

The verdict No gain

Would not make the best starting line-up.

Reported by CaughtOffside. Rating: PLAIER model.

Poll

Do you agree with the verdict?

–
0 votes
Comments (0)

What do you think of the transfer?

No comments yet. Be the first.
Premier League

More transfers