Phil Neumann of Birmingham City is reportedly on Nottingham Forest's radar. As things stand, this is a rumour, and there is no evidence of concrete talks or even an agreement. AC Fiorentina are also linked with the player, so Forest might not be alone in the pursuit of Neumann.
In sporting terms, the PLAIER assessment is sobering for the Premier League club. Neumann does not make the team better, as he sits below Nottingham Forest's current squad level. Anyone fighting for points in the Premier League needs reinforcements who can help the team immediately. According to the available data, Neumann does not currently meet that requirement.
The offensive numbers back this up. Neumann records a flat 0.0 for both xGoals and xPoints. He therefore makes no measurable contribution to expected goals and expected points. For a team that measures its performances by such metrics, this is a clear warning sign, especially since a new signing should ideally turn extra goal threat or defensive stability into tangible results.
According to PLAIER, his fair market value is 1.9 million euros. That is a manageable sum that would limit the financial risk. Nevertheless, even a cheap transfer makes little sense if the player does not raise the quality of the squad. For Nottingham Forest, Neumann would therefore be more of an option for squad depth than a player who moves the team forward in the league. If the rumour becomes something more, the club would have to present good arguments beyond the bare numbers.


