Home / Premier League / Ivan Toney
Rumour: Ivan Toney → Manchester United

Toney to Manchester United? He wouldn't make the starting line-up

No gainPremier League, RumourBench
11 November 2026 at 23:01 · 1 min read
Ivan Toney
No gainWould not make the best starting line-up
Goals per season0
Fair market value€7.0m
FromAl-Ahli
ToManchester United

Manchester United are reportedly looking at Ivan Toney. The Al-Ahli striker is said to be among the names on the Red Devils' list. There is no knowledge of concrete talks or even an agreement, so for now it remains a rumour.

The PLAIER assessment is sobering for United. Toney would not make the team better and, according to the analysis, would not make the best starting XI. For a club that wants to strengthen its attack in a targeted way, that is a clear warning sign. A new signing should at least add to the first eleven, and ideally lift it. According to the analysis, Toney currently does not meet that standard.

The numbers do not support him either. Both xGoals and xPoints show a value of 0.0. The player would therefore deliver neither additional expected goals nor additional expected points. For a team that wants to compete at the top of the Premier League, that would be a weak basis for an investment.

According to PLAIER, the fair market value is 7.0 million euros. That is a manageable sum, but it would only make sense if the sporting benefit were clear. As things stand, the data suggests that United would be better off directing the funds towards a forward who genuinely strengthens the starting XI. Until the rumour becomes more concrete, Toney remains a side note on the list of candidates.

The verdict No gain

Would not make the best starting line-up.

Reported by Tuttomercatoweb. Rating: PLAIER model.

Poll

Do you agree with the verdict?

–
0 votes
Comments (0)

What do you think of the transfer?

No comments yet. Be the first.
Premier League

More transfers